Lectures on Quantum Measurement Theory: IV

Lecture IV: Instruments in classical mechanics, quantum field theory, and cognitive science

In algebraic quantum field theory, measurements describable by interactions between the field and the measuring apparatus are characterized by the class of completely positive instruments that satisfy the condition called the normal extension property (NEP) (Okamura-Ozawa 2016).

In classical mechanics, traditionally only non-invasive measurements—those with trivial interaction—were considered admissible, for the observability of the trajectory of motion. Here, however, the full class of measurements realizable by classical-mechanical interactions is characterized in terms of instruments with NEP for the basis of the study of invasive measurements of classical systems.

Cognitive processes are also represented by completely positive instruments, along with the long-standing paradigm provided by von Helmholtz, who described a sensation-perception process as a sort of measuring interaction and referred to it as an unconscious inference. This framework is used to show the compatibility of the question order effect and the response replicability effect (Ozawa-Khrennikov 2019), which failed to be explained in an earlier approach using only projective measurement models. It is shown that there exists an instrument model, realizing both the question order effect and the response replicability effect, that is also capable of almost faithfully reproducing public-opinion survey data such as the well-known Clinton-Gore survey by Gallup in 1997 (Ozawa-Khrennikov 2021).